One of the best things about guitar picks is that, as familiar as the traditional basic pick may be, that's only the beginning of what's available. If you want a specialized playing feel, there are tons of options waiting to deliver it. For instance, the Dunlop 475 Big Stubby Guitar Picks have the same profile in a beefier contour, while specialty models like the ZeroGravity Orbit Guitar Pick feature extended grips and finger holes to provide even more control while you play.
Even if specialty shapes don't interest you, maybe premium materials do? Some picks, like the Dava Jazz Grips Pick 6 Pack, come with a rubberized layer for more secure handling. Others are made from futuristic materials - check out the Dunlop Max Grip Jazz III Carbon Fiber Guitar Picks for example. Or, if you're looking for a more retro style, how about a tortex or tortoiseshell pick such as the Fender 346 Shell Guitar Pick? The choice is yours to make.
No matter which guitar picks you choose, they're the right ones - that's just the way it is when something is as subjective a choice as this. Picks are a matter of preference, and many guitarists like to have multiple different kinds on hand so they can choose the best one for each performance. So don't be afraid to go all-out and build a big collection! The expression "the more, the merrier" definitely applies to guitar picks.